
arjunaviṣādayogaḥ · 1.42
continues Arjuna’s chain of consequences.
।
॥१.४२॥
saṅkaro narakāyaiva kulaghnānāṁ(ṅ) kulasya ca ।
patanti pitaro hyeṣāṁ(l) luptapiṇḍodakakriyāḥ
"This confusion in family and dharma leads to downfall for the family-destroyers and the family; their ancestors also fall, being deprived of food-and-water offerings."

Tap or click the image to view the full illustration.
This shloka continues Arjuna’s chain of consequences.
In the previous shloka, Arjuna said that when adharma overtakes the family, the women of the family become corrupted, and from that arises varṇa-saṅkaraḥ [confusion regarding varṇāśrama-dharma]. Now he explains the next result.
He says, saṅkaraḥ narakāya eva — “this saṅkara certainly leads to naraka.” Saṅkaraḥ here means confusion or intermixture in the family and dharmic order. It is not merely social confusion. In Arjuna’s argument, it means a breakdown in the clear transmission of family duties, ritual duties, and varṇāśrama responsibilities.
Narakaḥ means hell or downfall. In this context, the fall is religious and spiritual. When dharma and ritual order are lost, the family becomes disconnected from sacred duties. Arjuna sees this as a serious fall.
Then he says, kulaghnānāṁ kulasya ca — “for the destroyers of the family and for the family itself.” Kula-ghnāḥ [destroyers of the family] are those who cause the collapse of family dharma. Arjuna says that both the destroyers and the family line suffer the consequences.
Then he adds another serious consequence: patanti pitaro hyeṣāṁ — “their ancestors also fall.” Pitaraḥ [ancestors] are not forgotten in this ritual worldview. The family is not only a connection among living people. It also links the past, present, and future generations.
Why do the ancestors fall?
Because they become lupta-piṇḍodaka-kriyāḥ — deprived of the rites of food and water. Piṇḍa-kriyā refers to the offering of food, especially in śrāddha. Udaka-kriyā refers to water-offerings, such as tarpaṇa. Lupta means lost, deprived, or discontinued. So lupta-piṇḍodaka-kriyāḥ means that the śrāddha and tarpaṇa rites are no longer performed for the ancestors.
Helping the poor, feeding people, and serving society are also important. That is manuṣya-yajña [duty toward human beings]. But that does not replace pitṛ-yajña [duty toward ancestors]. Service to people can accompany ancestor-duty, but it does not become the same duty.
Each yajña [sacred duty or offering] has its own place. Gratitude to ancestors is not the same as charity to society. Both are valuable, but they are not identical.
The ritual context is important. Arjuna is speaking from a society where Vedic rituals, śrāddha, tarpaṇa, gotra, sūtra, and family-based practices mattered deeply. From the standpoint of general values like kindness, truthfulness, and discipline, one should not get trapped in rigid social identity. But from the standpoint of ritual continuity, lineage and family practice had a specific place.
This shloka teaches that when family dharma collapses, ritual continuity collapses, and even gratitude to ancestors is lost; Arjuna’s concern is real, but he is still using that true concern to support withdrawal from the dharma-yuddha [righteous war], so the final understanding is not “rituals matter, therefore abandon dharma,” but “rituals, gratitude, and family continuity matter, and therefore dharma must be protected with clarity.”
